New Kirby – Jack Kirby Collector #43 – quick notes

by

Initial reactions to the latest issue, available now in finer comic shops and from TwoMorrows.

The cover is a 1980s Silver Surfer piece, newly inked by Joe Sinnott. The original was kind of loose, so Sinnott does quite a bit of fleshing out of the details, especially on the background, which he’s certainly qualified to do (yes, I have a double standard when it comes to requiring faithful inking of Kirby). The original appears inside. The backcover is an early version of Silver Star from the mid-1970s, drawn and coloured by Kirby (and as we find out inside partially digitally restored for this printing) and a few other colour images related to interior articles.

The announcement of the Kirby Museum is up first, including a great photo of Kirby with his parents at age 3, some of the tentative plans for the project and a hint of a SILVER STAR GRAPHITE EDITION to go with the existing CAPTAIN VICTORY edition sometime next year. I’m always forgetful on Silver Star history so I don’t know exactly what would be in this.

Mark Evanier’s article this time around is on inkers, specifically Colletta. I think he mostly makes good points, although I think in balance he’s a bit too generous to Colletta, but then I’m kind of sick of the whole Colletta argument (other than taking a cheap shot on the weblog every few months).

The full story reprint this issue is the 8-page “His Best Friend’s Sweetheart” from YOUNG ROMANCE #3, a good early example of the S&K work in the genre, about a girl who waits for her man during the war, and copes with the unwanted attentions of the friend he asked to look out for her both before and after his return. Great stuff, nice look at post-war life in America, plus a nice unpublished TRUE DIVORCE page from the 1970s included for a look at Kirby’s last try at the genre.

First Gallery section is devoted to the Captain America story in TALES TO ASTONISH #93, with four full finished pages inked by Sinnott printed full-page next to their uninked counter-parts. Great looking pages, and interesting to see exactly what Sinnott added to the process.

Second Gallery is devoted to 1980s work, with pages from various projects printed with pencils beside the inked versions (plus an unused pencil-only Bruce Lee / Phantom Force page). A good look at the techniques, I was especially interested in seeing the DESTROYER DUCK page, where Alcala used Kirby’s main linework but did a lot of his own shading. Also a very nice is the SATAN’S SIX page.

There’s a good speech and Q&A session from a 1966 convention in here. Kirby’s in fine form, very funny (KIRBY: Roy has asked me to announce that there’ll be a refreshment period. ROY: No, a question period. KIRBY: Well, if there’s a refreshment period, it’s on me). He also mentions the “extras” in his crowd scenes being people from his life, like his brother-in-law or old landlord, which came up here a few weeks ago.

The Kirby Obscura article looks at some more nice 1950s stuff, including one I’m now in love with based on the splash page. “Lone Shark”, the story of a mutant killer shark, narrated by the shark. I hope they reprint that. The splash from the DC published “The Two-Dimensional Man” is also great.

A big part of this issue is a series of articles/interviews with people who Lisa Kirby presented with a “Jack Kirby Award” last year, various friends and associates, including a long interview with Steve Sherman and his brother Gary. I haven’t read all of those yet, just quickly scanned them and looked at the art included, but there are some interesting anecdotes about the Kirby family life in California. Lots of interesting photos and artwork, including a very different early Devil Dinosaur proposal (originally a modern day “hidden land” type story, including remnants of Atlantis and an old Nazi sub crew) and an unused Captain Victory page and a very odd photo-comic proposal STARBABY (printed in colour on the backcover). Looking forward to reading through this section.

Marvel’s Greatest Comics #94 [1980] – The Day That Ant-Man Failed

by

Having a few more pages to fill when comics reversed their shrinking page-count in 1980, Marvel split the Ant-Man story from TALES TO ASTONISH #40 (1963) in two issues of MGC behind post-Kirby FF reprints. This issue has the first six pages (with the last edited slightly, removing two panels to allow for the statement of ownership, which reveals that in 1980 an about-to-be-cancelled book reprinting 10-year-old FF stories could sell almost 100,000 copies a month).

This first part sets up the story of a series of mysterious truck hijackings, which Ant-Man hears about when he gets a signal transmitted from a series of ants. No really. And it gets better, to one of the most beautifully absurd scenes in a 1960s Marvel comic (and there are a lot to choose from). To get to his destination, Ant-Man shoots himself out of a gun, and has a group of ants converge to cushion his fall. Only he overshoots, almost hits a brick wall head-on, but for the quick thinking of his loyal ants.

Marvel's Greatest Comics #94 [1980]

Man, that’s just crazy. The rest of the story sets up Ant-Man’s plan to capture the hijacker, only to find himself suddenly taking ill (and riding an ant to a doctor), leaving the truck defenseless. These early Ant-Man stories aren’t the best, but they do have some great scenes, and give Kirby a chance to do some weird perspective shots and of course lots of ants.

Sol Brodsky inks this story, one of the few non-cover examples of him inking Kirby (the other more notable one being FF #3 and #4). It’s very nice, a shame he didn’t do more inking of Kirby back then. I’m only judging from reprints, so maybe I’m wrong, but he seems to be among the closest to how Kirby would have inked the work himself.

Published 1980

Adventure Comics #93 [1944] – Cover

by

Just S&K covers on this part of the run of Sandman in ADVENTURE. Seems their adventures got a little more surreal as time went on, too. That’s a great looking monster, plus the little bits of business on those strange creatures are nice.

And don’t forget to back the 5th War Loan.

AdventureComics93_441.jpg

Published 1944

True Bride-To-Be Romances #19 [1956] – Cover

by

More mid-1950s romance published by Harvey. I love the older couple in the background on this one, and the blurb “No place is home when a girl marries a rolling stone. Read Trailer Bride!”

With Kirby capable of covers like these, I wonder why so many of the Prize romance books had photo covers.

TrueBrideToBeRomances19_440.jpg

Published 1956

Kamandi, The Last Boy On Earth #26 [1975]

by

Kamandi and Ben Boxer make their way up to Canada and “The Heights of Abraham”, now home to giant mutated birds, insects and plants. And it hasn’t escaped the grasp of Sacker…

Kamandi, The Last Boy On Earth #26 [1975]

Lots of big art in this issue, with great scenes like Kam and Ben hitching a ride on a giant bird, the lush mutant plantlife in Quebec, all sorts of giant insects (including more of Kliklak’s species) and ending with the introduction of the British bulldog soldier and his giant ant, setting up one of my favourite Kamandi stories in the following issues.

D. Bruce Berry inks the 20-page story and cover, and Kirby handles the letter column himself this issue, interestingly running a lot more critical letters than normal. Also some weird answers. “But save me a lollipop, too, unless you want me to cry real loud and wake up your grandmother”.

Published 1975

The Amazing Spider-Man #1 [1963] – Cover

by

One of the most famous and oft-reprinted of the Kirby cover-only books, inked by Steve Ditko (obviously quite heavy on the Spider-Man figure, which looks like almost pure Ditko). I do love the layout, with the Torch’s flame circling around the rest of the FF and Spider-Man.

AmazingSpiderMan1_438.jpg

Published 1963

Marvel Milestone Edition – Avengers No. 4 [1995]

by

Another from the series of cover-to-cover reprints Marvel did in the 1990s, this one reprinting AVENGERS #4 from 1964. Very odd issue when you try to describe it, with lots of stuff going on. Namor finding Cap, the Avengers finding him later, the Avengers getting turned into statues, Cap finding the alien resonsible, who had been working for Namor and now gets the Avengers’ help, Namor attacking the Avengers. Fun, but kind of reads like they didn’t know where they were going from one page to the next.

av4

Lots of great artwork in the story, though, scenes that are at the heart of Marvel mythology. The death of Bucky, scene, of course, the retrieval of Cap. I’ve always been fond of the cop who had seen Cap as a kid with his “Forgive me, Cap, willya? I- I seem to have something in my eye” line.

George Roussos inks the 23-page story and cover (and they use the cover they always have in the reprints, with the skewed wings on Cap’s mask instead of the even ones the original printed version had). Can’t say I cared for the look much, just like most of his FF, this one seemed especially rushed especially with the backgrounds, although some bits are nicely done.

Published 1995

–Link– Evanier on Kirby bio

by

Mark Evanier has a few comments about the recent Kirby panel, as well as an update on the status of his upcoming biography of Kirby and efforts to make it as complete and accurate as possible.

http://www.newsfromme.com/archives/2005_07_31.html#010154

Wyatt Earp #26 [1959] – Cover

by

Boy, there’s nothing but trouble in Dodge for Wyatt, easily the best dressed of the western stars of Marvel. Christopher Rule is the attributed inker of this one from the Kirby Checklist, but as usual those credits are open to debate. I don’t see some of the signs that other Rule-attributed covers have on this one.

WyattEarp26_435.jpg

Published 1959

–Link– Sanderson on Kirby panel

by
Posted in Links.

Peter Sanderson’s “Comics in Context” column has a lengthy rundown of the San Diego Con panel on Jack Kirby from a few weeks ago. There’s a brief bit in the intro, then the actual article on the panel starts on page two. Some interesting stuff, a lot of stuff about credits and compensation for Kirby’s work. Mark Evanier mentions that the first draft of his Kirby bio is almost finished and he hopes to announce publishing plans next year. Plus there’s a comment suggesting not buying the upcoming MAXIMUM FANTASTIC FOUR reprint of FF #1 [Evanier later clarifies on his site that he meant not buying it just for Evanier’s commentary]. Some info on the Kirby Museum as well, and lots of fun anecdotes about the Kirbys to balance out the darker parts of how he got ripped off. Good reading, I can’t wait until the transcript appears in TJKC (presumably in #44). While you’re there, you can read Sanderson’s coverage of the 2003 panel (transcribed in TJKC #40)

http://comics.ign.com/articles/637/637694p1.html