Monthly Archives: August 2006

Not Kirby, Young Romance #51 “The Way They Met”

Young Romance #51
Young Romance #51 (November 1952) “The Way They Met” by Jack Kirby

Well I guess I misnamed this series because now I want to provide a Kirby work that the Checklist missed. Even though it is a one page work it has all the signs of Kirby penciling. The inking is typical S&K studio style. Generally I am unwilling to hazard a guess, but in this case I believe the spot inking was done by Jack himself.

Posted in 2006/08, 5 Studio, Kirby Or Not, Periods, Prize, Topic, z Archive | Leave a comment

Not Kirby, Young Romance #47 “A Man For My Birthday”

Young Romance #47
Young Romance #47 July1952) “A Man For My Birthday” by Bill Draut

Originally the Checklist indicated this was penciled by Kirby and inked by Simon. In the update (JKC #32) the inker was listed as Draut. Well the update is correct about the inker being Bill Draut, but he was also the penciler. In fact the entire store is done in a style so similar to other Bill Draut stories I am not at all sure why this one was singled out. I have no doubts that Draut not Kirby drew this piece.

Posted in 2006/08, 5 Studio, Kirby Or Not, Periods, Prize, Topic, z Archive | Leave a comment

Not Kirby, Young Love #55 “Love War” not “The Baby Dolls”


Young Love #55 (March 1954) “Love War” by Jack Kirby

The Jack Kirby Checklist lists “The Baby Dolls” (Young Love #55) as penciled by Jack Kirby. But in fact there is no story by that name in that comic. Young Love #55 has the story “Love War” that is not listed in the Checklist. There is a “Baby Doll” story in Young Love #31 (March 1952) but it was not done by Kirby. I think we can be pretty certain that some clerical error has occurred and the wrong title was listed for YL #55.

Posted in 2006/08, 5 Studio, Kirby Or Not, Periods, Prize, Topic, z Archive | Leave a comment

Not Kirby, Young Love #12 “Problem Clinic”

Young Love #12
Young Love #12 (August 1950) “Problem Clinic” by Mort Meskin

The Jack Kirby Checklist lists “Problem Clinic” (Young Love #12) as Kirby pencils and Simon inks. Not signed but clearly Mort Meskin pencils and inks. No Jack Kirby.

Mort did a lot of work for Simon and Kirby but so did Bill Draut and John Prentice as well as a host of other artists. Yet Mort has been mistaken for Jack Kirby more then any of the others.

Posted in 2006/08, 5 Studio, Kirby Or Not, Periods, Prize, Topic, z Archive | Leave a comment

Not Kirby, Young Love #12 “Smooth Operator”

Young Love #12
Young Love #12 (August 1950) “Smooth Operator” by Mort Meskin

The Jack Kirby Checklist lists “Smooth Operator” (Young Love #12) as Kirby pencils and Simon inks. Once again it is signed as Mort, although it is hard to see because it is in an brown area on the lower right of the splash. And once again typical Meskin pencils and inks. I cannot see any sign of Kirby.

Posted in 2006/08, 5 Studio, Kirby Or Not, Periods, Prize, Topic, z Archive | Leave a comment