Please donate!
The Jack Kirby Museum is raising funds to open a "Pop-Up" Museum on the Lower East Side, near where Kirby was born and raised. Learn more here.About this Blog:
© 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 & 2011 Harry Mendryk. Unless otherwise marked, all images are my own restorations. Further some of the images have copyrights by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby or Joe Simon alone. I am fortunate that Joe Simon has allowed me to also include some previously unpublished material. Please do not copy from this blog without permission.Pages
Categories
- 9/11 (6)
- Artists (268)
- Albistur, Jo (7)
- Avison, Al (8)
- Belfi, John (4)
- Breifer, Dick (9)
- Brewster, Ann (7)
- Burgos, Carl (1)
- Ditko, Steve (2)
- Donahue, Vic (12)
- Draut, Bill (50)
- Eadeh, Al (16)
- Gregg, George (5)
- Infantino, Carmine (6)
- Kirby, Jack (157)
- McCarty, Bob (9)
- Meskin, Mort (69)
- Morrow, Gray (1)
- Oda, Ben (1)
- Oleck, Jack (2)
- Powell, Bob (1)
- Premiani, Bruno (9)
- Prentice, John (29)
- Riley, Ken (2)
- Robinson, Jerry (10)
- Severin, John (7)
- Simon, Joe (57)
- Stallman, Manny (7)
- Starr, Leonard (13)
- Stein, Marvin (20)
- Walton, Bill (5)
- Checklist (19)
- Albistur, Joe (1)
- Brewster, Ann (1)
- Briefer, Dick (1)
- Donahue, Vic (1)
- Draut, Bill (1)
- Eadeh (1)
- Gregg, George (1)
- Infantino, Carmine (1)
- Kirby, Jack (1)
- McCarty, Bob (1)
- Premiani?, Bruno (1)
- Prentice, John (1)
- Riley, Ken (1)
- Robinson & Meskin (1)
- Severin, John (1)
- Simon, Joe (1)
- Stallman, Manny (1)
- Starr, Leonard (1)
- Stein, Marvin (1)
- Comic Checklists (20)
- All For Love (1)
- Black Magic, DC (1)
- Black Magic, Prize (1)
- Boys' Ranch (1)
- Charlie Chan (1)
- Clue (1)
- Fighting American (1)
- Foxhole (1)
- Headline (1)
- In Love (1)
- Justice Traps the Guilty (1)
- My Date (1)
- Personal Love (1)
- Prize Comics Western (1)
- Real West Romance (1)
- Western Love (1)
- Young Brides (1)
- Young Love (1)
- Young Romance (1)
- Your Dreams (1)
- Ink Checklist (1)
- Kirby, Jack (1)
- Periods (396)
- 1 Early (22)
- 2 Fox (14)
- 3 Timely (44)
- 4 DC (early) (46)
- 5 Studio (135)
- 6 Mainline (68)
- Assorted (10)
- Bullseye (8)
- Fighting American (6)
- Foxhole (13)
- In Love (16)
- Police Trap (7)
- Prize (15)
- 7 Freelance (74)
- Archie (13)
- Atlas Kirby (14)
- DC Kirby (4)
- Harvey (27)
- Prize (17)
- 8 Marvel (12)
- Assorted (6)
- Marvel Kirby (6)
- 9 DC (late) (6)
- Late (3)
- Serial Posts (139)
- Art of J. Simon (1)
- Art of Romance (41)
- Criminal Artists (4)
- Early Jack Kirby (9)
- End of S & K (1)
- Harvey Horror (3)
- It's a Crime (1)
- Kirby Austere Inking (1)
- Kirby Inkers (4)
- Little Shop of Horrors (1)
- Margin Notes (5)
- Replacing S&K (4)
- S&K Colorists (3)
- Start of S&K (12)
- Wide Angle Scream (15)
- Topic (341)
- Alternate Takes (16)
- Anthologies (6)
- Art Editing (4)
- Best of Simon & Kirby (2)
- Captain America (5)
- Comicscope (3)
- Experts (3)
- Featured Work (64)
- First Romance (1)
- Ghosting (7)
- Harvey Covers (24)
- Kirby Inking Kirby (4)
- Kirby Krackle (3)
- Kirby Or Not (28)
- Lettering (13)
- My Two Cents (7)
- Odds & Ends (128)
- Publications (24)
- Quote (4)
- Restoration (3)
- Robots (3)
- S&K Superheroes (2)
- Swiping (8)
- Wertham & Censoring (5)
- Why Comics Declined (1)
- Uncategorized (51)
- z Archive (595)
- 2006/03 (16)
- 2006/04 (14)
- 2006/05 (15)
- 2006/06 (16)
- 2006/07 (10)
- 2006/08 (24)
- 2006/09 (11)
- 2006/10 (19)
- 2006/11 (20)
- 2006/12 (14)
- 2007/01 (16)
- 2007/02 (17)
- 2007/03 (14)
- 2007/04 (10)
- 2007/05 (12)
- 2007/06 (8)
- 2007/07 (7)
- 2007/08 (8)
- 2007/09 (6)
- 2007/10 (10)
- 2007/11 (7)
- 2007/12 (4)
- 2008/01 (4)
- 2008/02 (7)
- 2008/03 (12)
- 2008/04 (8)
- 2008/05 (8)
- 2008/06 (11)
- 2008/07 (6)
- 2008/08 (12)
- 2008/09 (7)
- 2008/10 (8)
- 2008/11 (4)
- 2008/12 (6)
- 2009/01 (10)
- 2009/02 (4)
- 2009/03 (5)
- 2009/04 (8)
- 2009/05 (6)
- 2009/06 (5)
- 2009/07 (8)
- 2009/08 (6)
- 2009/09 (5)
- 2009/10 (6)
- 2009/11 (4)
- 2009/12 (3)
- 2010/01 (6)
- 2010/02 (7)
- 2010/03 (7)
- 2010/04 (4)
- 2010/05 (7)
- 2010/06 (5)
- 2010/07 (8)
- 2010/08 (4)
- 2010/09 (6)
- 2010/10 (9)
- 2010/11 (5)
- 2010/12 (5)
- 2011/01 (4)
- 2011/02 (2)
- 2011/03 (5)
- 2011/04 (6)
- 2011/05 (3)
- 2011/06 (5)
- 2011/07 (7)
- 2011/08 (5)
- 2011/09 (4)
- 2011/10 (10)
- 2011/11 (6)
- 2011/12 (5)
- 2012/01 (3)
- 2012/02 (2)
- 2012/03 (8)
- 2012/04 (3)
- 2012/05 (2)
Comic related blogs
Groups (membership required)
Web pages
Category Archives: Publications
Spirit World
I got a pleasant surprise when I visited my comic book store last night, DC’s reprint of Spirit World. What a marvelous time this is for Kirby fans as more and more of his work is being reprinted. Had someone told me a decade ago that DC would reprint Spirit World I would not have believed them, actually I would have thought they had lost their grip on reality. Spirit World was by no means a Kirby classic. It received remarkably poor distribution. Mark Evanier describes not being able to locate any copies at newsstands but finding bundles of them at a distributor’s warehouse that had never been delivered. DC’s confidence in it was so low that it was cancelled after a single issue, much too soon to be based on any sales figures. It is not even a cult classic, it rarely comes up in discussions about Jack Kirby’s art. But everything Jack did he did well so it is great to see this work back in print.

“Amazing Predictions” page 3 (from the reprint)
Kirby wanted Spirit World to be a high quality magazine printed in color but that is not the way DC would publish it. Instead a wash was applied to the line art and the results were printed using a dark cyan ink. Frankly it was not the best approach. But that is the approach that was originally made and was repeated for the reprint. Although I wish DC had initially followed Kirby’s wishes I believe their decision for the reprint to reproduced the effect of the original publication was the correct one. The quality of the reproduction in the reprint is exceptional. There are times when the original magazine was a little clearer but others where the reprint did a better job of presenting the art. But these differences are minor variations unnoticeable unless the two are compared side by side. One important improvement made for the reprint was the paper. I have never been a fan of using a yellowish paper in an attempt to match the current look of comic books. That look is due to aging and was not the look the books had when they first appeared. Using a yellowish paper for the Spirit World reprint would have darkened the cyan inked and ruined the effect. Instead DC has wisely used a flat white paper for this reprint.

“Amazing Predictions” page 3 (with Photoshop adjustment)
One of the special treats of Spirit World was all the collages that Kirby created for it. Kirby’s collages have been receiving more and more attention in recent years. Recently Steven Brower has devoted an article on the subject (Jack Kirby’s Collages in Context). I must admit that as a young reader I was not overly impressed with Jack’s collages but as an adult I greatly admire them. Part of the problem with the collages was the rather poor printing they originally received. I could not resist using Photoshop to convert one of the Spirit World collage to a better quality black and white. In my opinion it is a distinct improvement. However remember that Kirby originally meant Spirit World to be printed in color and take a look at the original art of the same collage that is included in Brower’s article. What a difference and what a lost opportunity that DC did not follow Kirby’s wishes.

“Witch Queen of Ancient Sumeria?” page 2 (from the reprint)
Spirit World was cancelled after a single issue but Kirby had already completed the art for the second issue. The Spirit World reprint includes the work that had been meant for Spirit World #2. I understand that these stories had been used in some of DC’s horror and mystery comics but the reprint only uses the line art. What a contrast between the two sections of the current book. While Spirit World #1 was inked by Vince Colletta and issue #2 by Mike Royer that is not the real reason for the difference in the appeal of the two sections. What is really shown is the rather detrimental affects of the wash and cyan ink had on the initial issue art. Kirby was at the top of his artistic form and it really shows in this last section.
There is a small essay in this latest book by Mark Evanier. Evanier’s writings have appeared in a number of books on Jack Kirby (including Titan’s The Best of Simon and Kirby). With good reason as there probably is no one more knowledgeable on Kirby (if only he would finally publish his full biography on Jack). But what Evanier has to say is particularly important concerning the Spirit World as he was present and involved in its creation.

“The Burners” page 6 (from the reprint)
Colleges played a small part in the second issue of Spirit World. But I could not resist including the sole exception. I hope to someday to discuss the Spirit World more fully, this has been more a review of the reprint book. I will not try to predict how successful the Spirit World reprint will be but I do believe it is a worthy addition to the collection of any Kirby fan.
Posted in 2012/05, 9 DC (late), Artists, Kirby, Jack, Periods, Publications, Topic, z Archive
Tagged Jack Kirby, spirit world
10 Comments
Hand of Fire: The Comics Art of Jack Kirby by Charles Hatfield
Hatfield devotes a chapter to discussing Kirby’s art and in particular his style. This section was of particular interest to me because it is by using aspects of an artist’s style, particularly seemingly insignificant ones, that an artist’s work can be identified. Much of the books’ discussion concerns applying, or rather attempting to apply, the theories of Charles Sander Peirce to Kirby’s work. I believe that Hatfield does a good job of describing Peirce’s theories, but then again since I was completely unfamiliar with them I cannot say how accurately they are presented. By his own admission applying Peirce’s theories on Kirby’s art is a difficult match but Hatfield feels that there is much to be learned from the attempt. It certainly provided me with an alternate way of looking at things which is the chief value in a book like “Hand of Fire”.
Hatfield also makes use of a definition of Will Eisner that “style results from the failure and frustration, from grappling with one’s own weaknesses as an artist and turning them to advantage”. While there is some truth in this, I feel it is only partial explanation of how an artist’s style is accomplished. Some aspects of an artist’s style may originate from his deficiencies, particularly earlier in a career. Kirby’s penchant for big ears during his first DC period comes to mind. But an artist style usually evolves over time and this generally is not due to any deterioration of his capabilities. Rather artist often go through a process of refining their work by filtering out what they consider unimportant aspects and emphasizing those of greater personal significance. Kirby’s style while working on the Fourth World books was, in my opinion, his best graphical efforts and this certainly not due to his failure to grapple with his weaknesses.
There is a chapter on the history and authorship of the Marvel Universe. It is a balance view which while emphasizing Kirby’s importance does not diminish or discredit Stan Lee’s contributions. I suspect Kirby Cultists will not be pleased but I was. Hatfield’s discussion of two common misapprehensions (that Marvel made superhero stories realistic and that the comics were created with a pre-planned continuity).
Included in the book is a lengthy analysis of Kirby’s work for DC, that what is commonly called the Fourth World. Hatfield obviously feels that this was the most important point of Kirby’s career. I admit that is an opinion that I do not share. But I still find his discussion about this work to be insightful and interesting. In fact the best that I have ever read.
“Hand of Fire” is not the type of book one would pick up to see great art. There is a small color section and some black and white illustrations scattered through the text. All the work shown was selected to match discussions in the text. So this is not a book to pick up just to see great Kirby art. But it is a great book if you want to enter into a discussion about Jack Kirby and his art. You may not agree with everything Hatfield writes, but you will understand why he takes the positions that he does and you may his ideas challenging.
Posted in 2012/04, Publications, z Archive
Tagged charles hatfield, hand of fire, Jack Kirby
2 Comments
The Next Two Simon and Kirby Library Volumes From Titan
Titan has announced the next two volumes for the Simon and Kirby Library as has been reported in Comic Book Resources. One of them, Horror, had been previously announced and is now scheduled for release in 2013. The book scheduled for the fall of 2012 is Science Fiction. Because the material in this volume was so dear to Joe Simon he held it back and it was not part of the original agreement with Titan. However recent events had caused those plans to be altered.
As I wrote above, the Simon and Kirby science fiction was very important to Joe. One of Joe’s earliest creations and the first that can be described as a real hit was Blue Bolt. It was while working on Blue Bolt that the Simon and Kirby collaboration took root. Most of the initial Blue Bolt stories had been previously reprinted some years ago in a small trade back. Considering the state of the art at the time it was a valiant effort but by today’s standards somewhat flawed. But the most puzzling thing about this earlier reprint was that it failed to include the origin story from the first issue. I am happy to write that the Titan volume will include first story and that all the stories have been fully restored. If you have seen the Crime volume from the Simon and Kirby Library you know what to expect. I showed Joe the Blue Bolt restorations a few weeks before his passing and he was quite pleased.
Who was the best Kirby inker is a much debated issue. I would say that nobody was better inking Kirby than Kirby himself closely followed by Joe Simon. But putting those two titans aside who did the best job inking Kirby? Of course most fans would probably chose some silver or bronze age inker. But I would say the best Kirby inking work appeared in Race for the Moon published in 1958. In his recent autobiography, “My Life In Comics”, Joe says this was the joint effort of Reed Crandall, Angelo Torres and Al Williamson. It was a beautiful job but one that did not live up to its full potential due to the notorious poor printing of Harvey Comics. Fortunately all of the Race for the Moon material will be restored in the Titan volume using either original art or flats (production proofs of the line art, the next best thing to original art). Altogether the Science Fiction book will include 82 pages based on original art and 18 from flats.
I could go on about all the important Simon and Kirby science fiction that will be in this volume including some surprises. And I probably will in a future post. But for now let me just say that this will be a very important Simon and Kirby volume that no fan will want to miss.
It is sad that Joe will not see the published results for either of these two volumes of the Simon and Kirby Library. But it is great that the Simon and Kirby legacy will continued to be published by Titan. The books being published by Titan are the only ones authorized by the estates of Joe Simon and Jack Kirby.
Posted in 2012/01, Publications, Topic, z Archive
3 Comments
The Simon and Kirby Library: Crime Makes the NY Times Best Selling List
Titan’s new book, “The Simon and Kirby Library: Crime” has made it to #5 on the NY Times best selling list of hardcover graphic books. There it is among such luminaries as Neil Gaiman (Sandman), Alan Moore (Neonomicon), Robert Kirkman (the Walking Dead), Graig Thompson (Habibi) and others. I think that is quite an accomplishment for comics produced over 60 years ago.
Posted in 2011/11, Publications, Topic, z Archive
Tagged Jack Kirby, Joe Simon, simon and kirby library: crime
Leave a comment
“Simon and Kirby Library: Crime” Has Been Released
While some individuals were fortunate enough to be able to pick up a copy of Titan’s latest release, “Simon and Kirby Library: Crime”, at the New York Comic Con it has not been available to the general public until this last week. I have seen a number of books reviews including one by USA Today (see links below) all of which are very favorable. Four of the links provide sample stories from the book and I will put them at the top of the list of links and provide the title of the story previewed.
I hope this book does well. As I mentioned previously crime and romance are my favorite Simon and Kirby genre. If this books sells well enough Titan may publish a second crime book that would include all the rest of S&K crime stories.
USA Today (“Queen of the Speed-Ball Mob”)
Crave On Line (“A Phantom Pulls the Trigger”)
boingboing (“Burned at the Stake”)




